Reference Documents

Friday, May 23, 2014

This Could Be Los Osos

USA Today reported that E. coli bacteria were found in the water supply of the area of and around Portland, Oregon. All water for drinking, food prep, tooth brushing and ice must be boiled for one at least one minute. 


NBC reported 670,000 customers were affected. 
"Animal waste" — fecal matter — in the water was the likely source of the E. coli, they said.
And in April, Portland had to divert 36,000 gallons of water out of a reservoir because a person peed into it.

http://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/e-coli-contaminates-portland-ore-tap-water-n113321

So here we sit Los Osos, people and animals alike, peeing and pooping ON TOP of our water supply. I can't wait until we are hooked up to our sewer and it is just the animals alone doing such. There are far less of them than of us, and the output is far smaller unless you have a Great Dane.

September Love...from the Regional Water Quality Control Board

Remember the song "September Love?" Or how about "See You in September?" That's the next step after today's Regional Water Quality Control Board informational meeting in San Luis Obispo on the topic of CDOs, or Cease and Desist Orders (September 22, 2014). Let's hope September's song will be in tune with what the community wants. Dump the CDOs! Take a step toward healing the community rift over inequity.

If you don't know the story, you probably don't want to. Let it be simply said, that the RWQCB was sick of having the sewer rug pulled out from under them by Los Ososians. Sewers 1 (by the County) and 2 (by the Los Osos Community Services District) were both stopped and there looked like little hope for a third iteration (due to the LOCSD's bankruptcy), so the RWQCB stepped in with a big disincentive to vote no to funding the next (State mandated) sewer, thrust upon the County of SLO to build (should they decide to accept the mission—they did). Thus the Los Osos CDO was born. Hook up by a certain date or expect to pay $5,000 per day to flush (or $10/gallon), plus pump your septic tank every three years.

In 2006, when these orders were first levied on 45 residents of the Prohibition Zone, the next step was to order a bunch more, continuing until every PZ household had one. But the hearings were so lengthy and onerous to both staff, board and citizens (read every meeting and every dollar in the Board's coffers could be dedicated to this task), the RWQCB stopped the process. So some people were under orders requiring them to pump their septic tanks and the rest of us were not. We only got Notices of Violation, which meant that if some day, when the sewer came along, if we didn't hook up, we'd get a Cease and Desist order. Some CDO holders got very, very upset, others just signed a settlement with the Board that they would hook up to the sewer when the time came.

These orders were in place since 2006 and might have gone away once the 218 vote had passed and the County started building sewer #3, had holders of those orders not decided to sue the RWQCB. That kept the orders in place—at least until the case was NOT accepted by the California Supreme Court, hence today's review of the CDOs and what to do about them.

Our District 2 Supervisor Bruce Gibson, many the CDO holders/friends of CDO holders and even me, a non-CDO holder, thought that they ought to go away, via written letters or by public testimony. They are unnecessary and unfair to those few under the mandate to pump when the rest of us don't. We should all be treated the same since no one will be suing the RWQCB any more!

So the Board will hear two items on this in September: an informational item to explain to the Board what the options are to vacating the CDOs and then a hearing to DO something about them, rescind them or not!

So mark your calendars for the SLO meeting of the Water Board in September for the next step in this seemingly endless, ever serpentine, sewer saga.

For the record, here was my speech:

My name is Lynette Tornatzky, I live in Los Osos and I have a Notice of Violation, not a Cease and Desist Order. I moved to Los Osos in April of 2005 and voted AGAINST the recall and AGAINST Measure B. I have been and still am in favor of your board holding the people of Los Osos responsible for cleaning up the obvious water pollution by ORDERS of some sort. 
However, considering the lawsuit against you by CDO holders was thrown out of court and not unlikely to come at you again, I support equality in the orders against us, whichever type they are—we should all NOW be under the SAME orders. 
There is always a chance, especially in Los Osos, that some people won't hook up to the sewer. But of the current 38 CDO orders that are in effect on less than 1% of the population out of a total of the approximately 4800 households, I would suggest that there is a far greater chance that the non-compliance would come from the sector that has Notices of Violation, the remaining 99% of Los Osos. 
I don't know what your enforcement process would look like to an NOV holder as opposed to a CDO holder. It seems to me that most CDO holders have just accepted a settlement and gone on with their lives. I don't know their backstories. I only know the very public and unhappy CDO holders that filed that PZLDF lawsuit against you which failed rather miserably and cost you a lot of money. But even those defiant ones seemed to have been complying with the CDO requirements. So knowing that—LOGICALLY, the category most likely TO not COMPLY would come out of the NOV-holder category.  
Since we are already paying part of the money of the sewer assessment on our taxes, to assess your risk in non-compliance, you might find out how many are protesting the sewer by not paying the sewer portion of tax on their property tax bill. I'd bet that the number is very small, and that those people are not all concentrated in the CDO-holder category. 
Looking at the staff report, the reasons for leaving the CDOs in place were three. On point #1, barring devastating earthquake or terrorism, I don't see how the County won't complete the sewer. They have gone through a hateful verbal fire-and-brimstone punishment for this project to be realized AND they have survived thus far; they are not going to quit now. I agree with points 2 and 3 though, SOMETHING should remain in place as a disincentive. 
However, looking at where the numbers of possible violators are placed, in the NOV category, it would make more sense that everyone should ACTUALLY be under a CDO if that effects a more likely compliance. BUT, looking at how costly that CDO process has been on you, I think putting everyone in the NOV category, where no hearings would need to occur until non-compliance occurs, would make the most sense. 
(I ran out of time, so didn't deliver this part.) Today's item is only for discussion, but I would hope that you might put this on a future agenda for action, either for Closed Session, as there may be things legal going on here that I don't know about or understand, or in a future Open Session. 
Thank you.

Thursday, May 15, 2014

Bid Dig Los Osos Adieu!

Dig Los Osos says the digging is just about complete! The last bits will be done in July. This is their LAST blog post, so please take a look!

http://www.diglososos.com/2014/05/15/final-farewell-from-dig-los-osos/

I for one am sorry to see you go. You have been a huge help to the community with all of your updates! Thank you for your wonderful help through these last two years!!! I wish you all the best in your next jobs!

Wednesday, May 14, 2014

Change Order Areas B & C!

Next Tuesday, May 20, 2014 at the Board of Supes:


Consent Agenda - Public Works Items:

15. Request for authorization of a Change Order for the Project Collection System Areas B & C Contract in the amount of $180,000 for additional collection system work, Los Osos Wastewater Project, Los Osos. District 2.

Watch .002% of the total budget elicit howls of outrage (start viewing at 9:00 AM next week, so as not to miss the performance)! Watch in person, on your computer or on Channel 21!

A link will be posted to the staff report when it becomes available!

Read the report and other documents at this link!

Sunday, May 11, 2014

Julie's Speculations: Tried in Truth Court, Fails (Miserably)

Julie Tacker wrote an opinion piece on CalCoastNews which, sadly for her, drops her credibility even lower due to many the misstatements and just plain untruths.

Let's go through them one by one:
Ogren likely chose to skip his stint as the LOCSD manager because in a sworn statement Buel admits Ogren directed Buel to back-date a contract that ultimately landed the district in court and was integral to the district ultimately filing for Chapter 9 bankruptcy.
Firstly, none of us has seen Mr. Ogren's resume. We must presume it was either a handout at the Wednesday meeting that you Julie must have attended, or you got it quickly through a public records request. OK, for this purpose of refutation, we believe that the LOCSD stint as IGM was not mentioned. You then make a wild assumption that this omission must be due to the back dating of a contract Ogren directed causing the bankruptcy!

NOT TRUE! Your board's stopping the project caused the bankruptcy! All the time, money and effort you and Lisa put in to trying to make the backdated contract a lawsuit was for absolutely NOTHING, it was and still is a non-issue! Spending money on speculative will-it-stick-on-the-wall issues like this is what caused the bankruptcy in Los Osos!

I won't even go into your silly speculations on a county official influencing a CSD director.
The only way to afford his exorbitant salary is to raise rates and/or sell Oceano’s most valuable asset – its water.
NOT TRUE! You really have no idea what monies he can save in crafting an actual budget, something so screwed up in Oceano, it hasn't managed a timely audit in years. For instance, the vacant accountant position will be his and the car allowance won't. Our new GM in Los Osos is still trying to unscramble the mess your board made of the money, so you are in NO position to opine on finances.
The OCSD last met in closed session on April 23rd and there was “no reportable action” taken. Somehow direction was given to legal counsel to negotiate and draft a contract.
Now Julie, you know how that works, remember the PZLDF contract with attorney Shaunna Sullivan that YOUR board wrote with no public knowledge at all, enraging even your supporters?
A tremendous amount of work went into finagling the formula in which to pay this kind of salary. How was this direction given by a majority of the board if there was no reportable action on the 23rd? The result smells of the all-to-often Brown Act violating practices that OCSD board members believe they are immune from. 
Yes, we in Los Osos would like to know how the reserves vanished under YOUR watch in 2006. Brown Act violations? Finagling? When did your board direct the GM to withdraw monies held in RESERVE for fire department and water department improvements because you had somehow spent those reserves AND had no funds left to pay the bond payment either! There is no public record on how or where that money went at all! Now that smells even to this day as we are still paying the money back! Your board did not have a clue as to the meaning of the word "transparency."
Ogren will likely be out of touch with its citizens.
Why? He certainly is very well acquainted with many Los Osos citizens in all income brackets.
 Los Osos Waste Water Project is mid-way through construction; already $10 million over budget and $15 to $20 million in lawsuits and claims for damages are lining up.
NOT TRUE! The project is NOT over budget, the extra costs for the treatment plant are WITHIN the budget. The lawsuit is Paavo's fault? NOT TRUE. And you don't even consider the County's counter suit as having any validity in this? You just assume ARB is correct? 
In Oceano, Ogren’s work as public works director at the county has been unsuccessful at getting a Habitat Conservation Plan in place for the Arroyo Grande Creek.
NOT TRUE!  it is listed in the Special Districts Budget for 2013/14. Page 5 reads: "The 2013/14 budget was endorsed by the Flood Control Zone 3 Advisory Committee on March 21, 2013. Ongoing efforts include the Arroyo Grande Creek Habitat Conservation Plan (HCP)…"
http://www.slocounty.ca.gov/Assets/AD/2013-14+Special+Districts+Budget.pdf

Perhaps Ms. Tacker is not aware of how long these things actually take. The one for Los Osos was stopped in 2005 due to the recall board stopping the sewer project. Since the county took over and began actual sewer project work, our plan is finally in the works again and with years ahead of it too.
Ogren is as a former employee of the Wallace Group.
So.....? What does that have to do with anything?
It did not go unnoticed that the South San Luis Obispo County Sanitation District, under the leadership of John Wallace, failed to hold the county responsible for flood-waters rising and pouring off the county owned airport contributing to the cause of the massive sewage spill.
Oh, so Mr. Ogren worked for the Wallace group, and the Wallace Group didn't ding the County on the spill.....because Mr. Ogren once worked for them? No. You are off-the-wall conflating responsibilities and events in an untrue and illogical manner.
http://www.sanluisobispo.com/2012/09/07/2216530/south-county-sanitation-district.html

The spill was on December 19 and 20. However, the County had already gone for a permit from the Water Board, called an Emergency Coastal Development permit, issued December 16. They were working on the upcoming problem. It was bad news for everyone that the spill happened, but it wasn't the County's fault, so John Wallace did not hold them accountable for a reason.
http://documents.coastal.ca.gov/reports/2011/1/F6-1-2011.pdf
Ogren’s departure from the county is welcomed.
No, it isn't. You speak only for yourself and the weekly anti-County ranting crew.
His arrival in Oceano will likely bankrupt the community services district and he needs just four years to do it.
It took your board less than a year to do in Los Osos. I guess you don't want to speculate that even someone you despise could do a "better" job at bankrupting a community than you did! Pitiful, really.

Saturday, May 10, 2014

Paavo Ogren to Leave County PW Director Job for Oceano GM Position

I have sat here for a few hours trying to write something. I have been in a sort of shock. Actually kind of fearful and depressed. Our head of SLO County Public Works, who has been with us pre-County sewer inception, is moving on from leading a large department of 180 in eight divisions, to a tiny staff of six in the beleaguered Oceano Community Services District. Talk about a change!

Well, we will all just have to get past the surprise, fear and depression, as I know I can't be the only one.

Sometimes a large job change is just needed. The sewer project is virtually in the bag. Really, aside from the ribbon cutting, should there be one, it is over half way to being done completely, all the parts left to go are already in place. It is under careful and excellent oversight. The other County projects are in good hands. (The lawsuit from ARB is so nothing compared to the CSD's bankruptcy over stopping the Tri-W project. Besides, what's a Los Osos sewer project without litigation?)

Life needs challenges, not glide paths. Paavo, you have done a stellar job for us in Los Osos. You have been essential to getting this reluctant town critical infrastructure for its health and our continued residency here. You have my gratitude and that of many others as well.  I wish you all the best.  Especially the odd joys of getting in there and fixing something that is an acknowledged mess. Oceano is beyond lucky to get you! I look forward to reading about Oceano's future successes.

Read the Tribune's story off this link:
http://www.sanluisobispo.com/2014/05/09/3058508/paavo-ogren-oceano-csd.html?sp=/99/100/&ihp=1


Wednesday, May 07, 2014

CDO ALERT!

OK, the time has come for the CDO issue to be on the agenda for the next Central Coast Regional Water Quality Control Board meeting on Thursday May 22, 2014 here in SLO!


NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING
Thursday, May 22, 2014, 8:30 a.m. - 7:00 p.m.
Friday, May 23, 2014, 9:00 a.m. - 5:00 p.m.

Central Coast Water Board Hearing Room
895 Aerovista Place, Suite 101, San Luis Obispo


See Item 14 under,

Discussion/Informational Items

      [Harvey Packard, 805/542-4639, harvey.packard@waterboards.ca.gov]

Click the link to see the page with links to the relevant documents!

Also of Los Osos' interest:
 Friday, May 23, 2014, 9:00 a.m. 

Closed Session

4.    Los Osos CSD v. Central Coast Water Board (San Luis Obispo County Case No. CV 060146 (TSO 00-131)
6.    Ken Berry, et al. v. Central Coast Water Board, et al. (Sacramento Superior Court; CEQA Challenge to Los Osos CDOs)


See you on Thursday, May 22!

The Softer Side of Sludge

Here is a very different take than SLO County's on sewer sludge at The Aichi Prefectural Toyo River Sanitation Center and other places in Japan:

http://mainichi.jp/english/english/features/news/20140505p2a00m0na002000c.html

The article states:
The Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism (MLIT) set up a strategy team for such "sewer assets" last summer, and this April, a public relations campaign was spearheaded with the publication of the first-ever cookbook using recipes of food grown from this method.


BOS 5-13-14 Ad for Construction Bids!

Next Tuesday at the Supes, South Bay Boulevard from Los Osos Valley Road to SantaYsabel has the number one spot on the Consent Agenda for approving a bid for construction of Asphalt Overlay!

Bid Opening:

1. Letter transmitting plans and specifications (Clerk’s File) for 2013-14 Asphalt Overlay, South Bay Boulevard from Los Osos Valley Road to Santa Ysabel Avenue, Los Osos, CA, for Board approval and advertisement for construction bids. Bid opening date set for Thursday, June 12, 2014. District 2.

When the relevant documents are up on the Supes site, I will post them! The sooner South Bay Boulevard gets fixed, the better. Construction vehicles have taken their toll to its surface.

Tuesday, May 06, 2014

A Select Group We Are!

Many, if not most of us living in Los Osos, came from someplace else. Some from larger towns or cities with sanitary infrastructure already in place, maybe even RE-placed by the time we were using it. Some from houses that had a septic tanks already in use (or maybe you were on a replacement tank at that point, a step up from the redwood barrel that once served the earlier homeowners. Not too many from the hippie days of an outhouse off in a field I would guess, although there may be a few who had that unique experience. What one does while camping way out in the sticks does NOT count, unless you LIVED there for months or years).

Think about it, in 2016, WE of the PZ are going to go where very few of us have gone before! We are getting brand spanking new, fresh sewer pipes to... to... So—! how many of us HAVE EVER HAD pristine, new pipes to christen!

Their use might be a small unnoticed event for many or most perhaps, this emergence into the 21st century of urban life with something the Romans had centuries ago. But my first flush might just be the contents of a bottle of champagne: first to reflect on and honor the humble pipes that took years of battle, money, hard work and tears to place into the ground. And I'll do it too for a future without that ever present drone of sewer anger cautioning and framing acceptable speech amongst my new acquaintances here in Los Osos.


Monday, May 05, 2014

Sewer Web Game!

Well, I couldn't get this to work. I installed the Unity Web Player for Mac (several times). "The Unity Web Player enables you to view blazing 3D content created with Unity directly in your browser, and autoupdates as necessary."  But it never launched using either Safari, Chrome or Firefox, which it is supposed to do but wouldn't, due to some sort of update problem. Poop. (I don't have a PC anymore, so I couldn't try it there.)

So maybe you might want to see if you can play an outer space, on-line sewer game! Good luck!

http://www.ludumdare.com/compo/2014/05/02/it-came-from-the-sewer-the-post-mortem/

If it doesn't work for you either, the author made a cool time-lapse video of creating the game! You can see that here:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jlN8nSGgQlU

Saturday, May 03, 2014

The Grim Future for Sewer Sludge in SLO-Co....

Sewer sludge aficionados probably do not exist in this county. Even the operators of the wastewater treatment plants that produce it are probably not that fond of it as it must be trucked out of the County, to Santa Maria or the San Joaquin Valley for disposal.

Of course, our wastewater treatment facility is not built yet, so this is more conceptual than personal to Los Osians at this point.......

At the Board of Supes Tuesday, May 6, 2014:

Hearings:
21. Hearing to consider an ordinance to continue the provisions and restrictions that were in place in the Land Application of Treated Sewage Sludge/Biosolids interim ordinance for a period of four years, and find the ordinance consistent with the previously approved Negative Declaration/Environmental Determination No. ED03-149. All Districts.

The relevant documents can be found here:


This is why it is not applied to land here:


Naturally, the sewage sludge industry feels differently about this!



The Times Press recorder tells us in an article published on March 25, 2013, 
"The county’s 17 wastewater treatment plants generate 11,500 tons of sewage sludge annually, with the majority of the material  6,100 tons trucked to a composting facility in Santa Maria. 
Some of the material does come back to the county in the form of fertilizer, while the other roughly 50 percent of the 11,500 tons of generated sludge is disposed of in landfills or hauled to the San Joaquin Valley for disposal."
Some day we will be adding our own personal contributions to this amount shown above and those who have not pumped for many, many years will add the most - go Al's!

World's Largest Sewer Related Research Program Wins Award!

"Sewer Corrosion and Odour Research Program: Putting Science in Sewers."

Read about it here!

http://www.uq.edu.au/news/node/113663

Little Known Sewer Rat Factoid



Seriously....

Good info if you intend to become a sewer rat wrangler for the movies however!

https://twitter.com/GreatDismal/status/459566192273813504

Public service notice for rat rescue, sewer or otherwise:

http://www.rathelp.org/Shelters.html